How Using AI Can Weaken Your Thinking

In short

  • Studies from 2025-2026 suggest that leaning too heavily on AI can hurt learning outcomes and thinking habits. There is no evidence that AI physically damages the brain.
  • In a PNAS study, students who practiced with standard GPT-4 scored 17% lower on a test without AI than students who never used it. An AI that gave hints instead of answers largely avoided the drop.
  • Try the problem first, ask for hints instead of explanations, explain it back without AI, and check again a few days later.

Are we getting smarter, or losing the ability to think for ourselves?

When a problem gets hard, we ask ChatGPT. When a concept makes no sense, we ask AI to explain it. Instead of reading a long paper, we ask for a summary. We get information faster and handle more work than ever.

But something odd happens. With AI, it feels like we can understand anything. Without it, solving things alone gets harder. Is that just a feeling?

Studies published in 2025 and 2026 warn that learning that relies too heavily on AI can hurt both learning outcomes and the thinking process itself. To be clear, there is no evidence that AI physically damages the brain. The problem is that while we hand our thinking to AI, we may lose chances to think and remember on our own.

1. Stage one: you hand the thinking over to AI

At first you use AI simply to save time. You look up a concept you don't know, or check the solution to a tricky problem. Gradually, you spend more time asking AI than working out the answer yourself.

In 2025, researchers at Microsoft Research and Carnegie Mellon University surveyed 319 knowledge workers. They found that the more people trusted AI, the less critical thinking they tended to do. The more you trust AI's output, the less effort you may put into analyzing and verifying it yourself.

This is a correlation from survey data, not proof that AI directly reduced anyone's thinking ability. What matters is that we can slip into a habit of delegating the thinking.

2. Stage two: you fall for the illusion of understanding

AI explanations are remarkably smooth. It turns complex ideas into simple analogies and step-by-step walkthroughs. While you read, everything seems to make sense.

But what if you close the screen and try to explain it to someone else?

A study presented at ACM CHIWORK 2026 compared how different ways of interacting with AI affect real learning among 85 people. The group using a standard AI rated their own understanding highly, yet had the lowest actual learning outcomes of the groups compared. When the AI prompted learners to explain things themselves, or offered hints, both understanding and learning outcomes improved.

A smooth explanation does not always become real understanding. Feeling that you understood an explanation is very different from being able to explain it yourself.

3. Stage three: it gets hard to solve problems without AI

A 2025 study in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS) tested how generative AI affects math learning among about 1,000 high school students. Students who used a standard GPT-4-based tool improved a lot during practice sessions where AI was available.

Then AI was taken away, and the result changed. The students who had used the standard AI tool scored 17% lower on the test than students who studied without AI. When the AI was designed to give hints instead of handing over the answer, this negative effect was largely avoided.

The difference is clear. Using AI to solve a problem and using AI to build your problem-solving skills are two different things. Performance with AI does not automatically become your own ability.

4. Stage four: the habit of thinking for yourself weakens

In 2025, researchers at the MIT Media Lab studied the relationship between AI-assisted writing and brain activity in 54 participants. Participants were split into three groups: an AI group, a search engine group, and a group writing with no tools.

EEG analysis showed the broadest brain connectivity in the group that wrote without tools, and comparatively lower connectivity in the AI group. The AI group also had more trouble accurately remembering what they had written.

This is a preprint with a small number of participants. A difference in brain connectivity does not mean lower intelligence or permanent brain damage. Still, it leaves an important question: are we using AI to think more deeply, or are we gradually removing our reasons to think?

So how should you use AI?

Not using AI is not the answer. The point is not to let AI do your thinking, but to use AI so that you think more.

  • Try solving the problem yourself before asking for the answer.
  • Ask AI for questions and hints instead of explanations.
  • After studying, explain the key ideas without any help from AI.
  • A few days later, recall it again and check whether you really remember.

Instead of consuming the answers AI gives you, you use the conversation to test your own thinking. That is the difference between simply studying with AI and actually learning through it.

In an age when AI thinks for us, we need to think deeper

obbler started from exactly this concern. It is an AI study app that goes beyond summarizing your material and handing out answers. It uses conversation to gauge how well you understand and helps you review over time.

We are not aiming for a world where AI answers every question. We want learners who can understand, explain and solve problems on their own, even without AI. What matters is not the time you spent using AI, but the knowledge that has actually become yours.

Think deeper. Learn better.

Start learning more deeply with obbler →

References

  1. Eleftheriou et al. (2026). Confidence Without Competence in AI-Assisted Knowledge Work. ACM CHIWORK 2026.
  2. Bastani et al. (2025). Generative AI without guardrails can harm learning: Evidence from high school mathematics. PNAS.
  3. Lee et al. (2025). The Impact of Generative AI on Critical Thinking. CHI 2025.
  4. Kosmyna et al. (2025). Your Brain on ChatGPT: Accumulation of Cognitive Debt when Using an AI Assistant for Essay Writing Task. arXiv preprint.

Study your own material with obbler

Add a PDF, photos, a link or a video. Chat about it and turn it into notes, flashcards and quizzes.

Download on the App Store